2016 |
|||
| Matt Greenman | WR | ECFC | First Team |
| Matt Greenman | RS | ECFC | First Team |
| James Comer | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Sean Chinova | LB | ECFC | First Team |
| Amir Young | OL | ECFC | Second Team |
| James Wolff | OL | ECFC | Second Team |
| Travis O'Brien | RB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Josh David | LB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Tyler Rogers | K | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| DeSean Hart | DB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
2015 |
|||
| Dom Spaulding | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Chris Toyloy | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Sean Chinova | LB | ECFC | First Team |
| Josh David | FB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Matt Greenman | WR | ECFC | Second Team |
| Matt Greenman | RS | ECFC | Second Team |
| Daniel Billy | DB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Devin Broadley | P | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Melquawn Pinkney | RB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Amir Young | OL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
2014 |
|||
| Matt Greenman | WR | ECFC | First Team |
| Jovan Wilkins | DB | ECFC | First Team |
| Dom Spaulding | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Anthony Sanders | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Sean Chinova | LB | ECFC | First Team |
| Andrew Miller | OL | ECFC | First Team |
| Kalyn Smithson | LB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Melquan Pinkney | RB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Devin Broadley | P | ECFC | Second Team |
| Derek Bent | DL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Jawad Yatim | QB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Troy Lawrence | OL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| David Bednarz | OL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Tyler Rogers | K | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Mike Green | TE | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
2013 |
|||
| Frank Civitello | OL | ECFC | Offensive Lineman of the Year |
| D'Andre Smith | DB/RS | ECFC | Rookie of the Year |
| Jordan Hyman | WR | ECFC | First Team |
| Mike Babich | TE | ECFC | First Team |
| Frank Civitello | OL | ECFC | First Team |
| D'Andre Smith | RS | ECFC | First Team |
| Jon Proto | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Jovan Wilkins | DB | ECFC | First Team |
| Jawad Yatim | QB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Matt Greenman | WR | ECFC | Second Team |
| Kayln Smithson | LB | ECFC | Second Team |
| D'Andre Smith | DB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Ned Cassidy | LB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Calvin Claiborne | DB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Andrew Miller | OL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Anthony Sanders | DL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Dominick Spaulding | DL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
2012 |
|||
| Mike Landers | Coach | ECFC | Coach of the Year |
| Matthew Bonomolo | OL | ECFC | Offensive Lineman of the Year |
| Chris McNally | RB | ECFC | First Team |
| Jordan Hyman | WR | ECFC | First Team |
| Matthew Bonomolo | OL | ECFC | First Team |
| Frank Civitello | OL | ECFC | First Team |
| Bobby Hemmann | K | ECFC | First Team |
| A.J. Knibbs | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Azim Carter | DB | ECFC | First Team |
| Jovan Wilkins | DB | ECFC | First Team |
| Scott Drosendahl | QB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Mike Babich | TE | ECFC | Second Team |
| Andrew Miller | OL | ECFC | Second Team |
| Jon Proto | DL | ECFC | Second Team |
| Doug Hanlon | OL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Jon Zullo | OL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Kayln Smithson | LB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Quan Lovett | DB | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
2011 |
|||
| Johrone Bunch | RB | ECFC | Offensive Player of the Year |
| A.J. Knibbs | DE | ECFC | Defensive Player of the Year |
| Johrone Bunch | RB | ECFC | First Team |
| A.J. Knibbs | DE | ECFC | First Team |
| Jovan Wilkins | DB | ECFC | First Team |
| Matt Valenti | WR | ECFC | Second Team |
| Frank Civitello | OL | ECFC | Second Team |
| Jon Proto | DL | ECFC | Second Team |
| Jah-Son Johnson | LB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Mackenson Charles | DB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Matt Bonomolo | OL | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
| Jovan Wilkins | RS | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
2010 |
|||
| Johrone Bunch | RB | ECFC | First Team |
| Nick Lynch | WR | ECFC | First Team |
| Erik Matos | OT | ECFC | First Team |
| A.J. Knibbs | DE | ECFC | First Team |
| Julien Baptiste | FS | ECFC | First Team |
| Scott Drosendahl | QB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Paul Shaughnessy | RB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Jon Proto | DT | ECFC | Second Team |
| Mike Brockenberry | LB | ECFC | Second Team |
| E.J. Murray | LB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Shane Gardner | SS | ECFC | Honorable Mention |
2009 |
|||
| Johrone Bunch | RB | ECFC | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Kyle Watkins | RS | ECFC | Special Teams Player of the Year |
| Johrone Bunch | RB | ECFC | First Team |
| Kyle Watkins | WR | ECFC | First Team |
| Nick Lynch | TE | ECFC | First Team |
| Michael Horn | OL | ECFC | First Team |
| Kyle Watkins | RS | ECFC | First Team |
| Eli Shuler | DL | ECFC | First Team |
| Julien Baptiste | DB | ECFC | First Team |
| Johrone Bunch | P | ECFC | First Team |
| David Green | LB | ECFC | Second Team |
| Shane Gardner | S | ECFC | Second Team |
ECFC - Eastern Collegiate Football Conference |
|||