| 2015-16 (GNAC) | |||
| Derek Polish | Sophomore | Bow, N.H. | |
| Cody Burdick | Junior | Saratoga Springs, N.Y. | |
| Nate Barron | Senior | Florence, Mass. | |
| Chad Coehlo | Junior | Salem, Mass. | |
| Joe Gengarelly | Sophomore | Sag Harbor, N.Y. | |
| Cam Hayward | Sophomore | Derry, N.H. | |
| Shayne Rix | Sophomore | Kingston, Mass. | |
| Tommy Thompson | Junior | Schuylerville, N.Y. | |
| Alex Veloukas | Junior | Salem, Mass. | |
| Alex Zito | Sophomore | Graphic Design | Marlboro, Conn. |
| 2014-15 (GNAC) | |||
| Nate Barron | Junior | Florence, Mass. | |
| Joe Galante | Senior | Framingham, Mass. | |
| Shaun Royce | Senior | South Windsor, Conn. | |
| Tommy Thompson | Sophomore | Schuylerville, N.Y. | |
| Alex Veloukas | Sophomore | Salem, Mass. | |
| 2013-14 (GNAC) | |||
| Joe Galante | Junior | Framingham, Mass. | |
| Shaun Royce | Junior | South Windsor, Conn. | |
| 2012-13 (GNAC) | |||
| Chaz Strom | Sophomore | North Grafton, Mass. | |
| 2011-12 (GNAC) | |||
| Brendan Hylan | Senior | Clinton Conn. | |
| Sean Maher | Senior | Ashland, Mass. | |
| 2010-11 (GNAC) | |||
| Michael Conway | |||
| Brendan Hylan | Junior | Clinton, Conn. | |
| 2009-10 (NAC) | |||
| Matt Vernik | Senior | Criminal Justice | Bethany, Conn. |
| 2008-09 (NAC) | |||
| Craig Heintzelman | Senior | Forensic Science | Windham, N.H. |
| Matt Vernik | Junior | Criminal Justice | Bethany, Conn. |
| Brett Conley | Senior | Business Management | Fairfield, Conn. |
| 2005-06 (NAC) | |||
| Bryan Smith | Junior | Criminal Justice | Worcester, Mass. |